Should a Diet for Diabetes Type 2 Include Bread?
Perhaps the most difficult change you will have to make in a diet for diabetes type 2 is avoiding white and wheat flour products such as bread and cereals. Brown bread may look like a healthy choice, but not all brown breads are whole grain. Most “whole wheat” (brown) bread produced in the United States is highly processed and made with enough brown flour to make it look brown.
The Glycemic index and glycemic load concepts
Before taking a look at some of the breads available in the market let us review what the terms glycemic index and glycemic load mean.
The glycemic index is simply a numerical way of describing how the carbohydrates in individual foods affect blood glucose levels. Foods with a high glycemic index value contain carbohydrates that cause a dramatic rise in blood glucose levels, while foods with a low glycemic index values contain carbohydrates that do not rise blood glucose levels that much. To obtain the glycemic index values, foods were compared to the effect that ingesting pure glucose has in healthy individuals.
The glycemic load: because both the amount and type of carbohydrate are needed to predict blood-glucose responses to a meal, researchers at Harvard University established a formula that they named the glycemic load. It is obtained by multiplying the GI value of a food by the amount of carbohydrate per serving and dividing by 100.
Calculating the glycemic load = GI value x carbohydrate per serving ÷ 100
Example: 1 cup of cooked spaghetti has an average GI value of 41 and contains 52 grams of carbohydrate
Glycemic load = 41 x 52 ÷ 100 = 21
These two concepts, the glycemic index and the glycemic load are important because when you eat a meal containing carbohydrate, your blood glucose rises and falls and the extent to which it rises and remains high is critically important to health. The glycemic index values can help you make better choices about foods to prevent your blood glucose from going too high and too fast.
How starch affects blood sugar
The starch contained in carbohydrates can affect the way blood sugar rises in two ways:
- The form of the starch. Starch in raw food is stored in hard, compact granules that make it difficult to digest. That is why potatoes can give you a stomach ache and produce a lot of intestinal gas if you ate them raw. When cooking, water and heat expand the starch granules to the point where they burst and free the starch molecules.If most of the starch granules have swollen and burst during the cooking process, the starch becomes a kind of gelatin (it is said to be fully gelatinized). The digestion of free starch molecules is very easy and fast because especial enzymes in charge of the digestion of starch in the small intestine have a greater surface area to attack.The quick action of the enzymes results in a rapid, high blood glucose rise after eating the food.A food containing starch that is fully gelatinized will therefore have a very high GI value.
- The effect of particle size in blood sugar. Another factor that affects blood sugar is the size of the particles of the food. The grinding or milling of grains reduces the particle size and makes it easier for water to be absorbed and enzymes to attack.That is why breads made from flours that have been finely ground tend to have a high GI value which means a high rise in blood sugar. The larger the particle size, the lower the GI value.
How fiber affects blood sugar
Another factor that influences your rise of blood sugar is fiber in foods. However, not all breads that have a substantial amount of fiber may be good for you. In fact, finely ground wheat fiber, such as the one contained in whole wheat bread, has no effect on the digestion of starch because the size of its particles is very small.
As a result, it can raise your blood glucose in spite of having fiber. Any product made with whole wheat flour which grains have been highly processed will have a GI value similar to that of white bread.
On the other hand, if the grain is whole and the fiber is still intact, it can work as a physical barrier to the enzymes and the digestion slows down. This is one of the reasons why whole (intact) grains usually have low GI values.
The type of fiber also makes the difference whether or not your blood sugar goes up. Viscous fiber thickens the mixture of food that enters the digestive tract. This slows the passage of food and restricts the movement of enzymes, thereby slowing digestion. The end result is a lower blood glucose response. Oats contain high amounts of this fiber.
A quick review of some breads available at the market
White bread is produced from wheat flour that has been finely chopped and from which the bran and the germ have been removed. In addition, the flour used in white bread is often bleached using chemical bleaching agents such as potassium bromate or chlorine dioxide gas to remove any remaining yellow color.
The process of removing the bran and the germ, known as milling, also removes important nutrients like dietary fiber, iron, and B vitamins among others. A law passed by the US government in 1941 however, mandates that bread manufacturers add some of the vitamins and minerals lost in the milling such as thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, folic acid, and iron.
You may have noticed on the package of certain breads the word ENRICHED; it refers to the process of replacing some of the vitamins and minerals.
White bread has a high average glycemic index of 70. It is not a good choice for diabetics or anyone else for that matter and should not be part of your diet.
To check the glycemic index of different breads you can go to “List of glycemic index list for different breads”.
Whole Wheat bread
Whole wheat bread is made from whole or almost whole wheat grains. The exact composition of whole wheat bread varies; in some cases the bread is made with whole grain flour that contains all of the component parts of the grain while in other cases the bread may only include a part of the bran or wheat germ.
The problem with whole wheat bread is that most of the times the grains are milled with steel rollers, a process that cuts the grains in very small particles. The smaller the particle size, the easier it is for water and enzymes to penetrate, thus finely milled whole-wheat and rye flours are digested and absorbed quite fast. Breads made using these procedures have high GI values.
Stone-ground wholemeal bread is made from 100 per cent wholemeal flour. This is flour that contains all the nutrients present in wheat and is made by grinding the grains between pairs of stones. Stone milling generally produces flour with coarser particles of dietary fiber than the ones produced with steel rollers.
The coarse particles of fiber slow digestion and consequently slow the blood glucose response. This bread is a better choice for diabetics than bread containing finer particles of fiber.
Whole grain pumpernickel (rye)
Pumpernickel bread is a form of German bread, referenced at least as far back as the 1450s. This bread is produced by combining coarse and fine rye flour with a sourdough starter and sometimes yeast. The bread then undergoes a slow cooking process, which can last up to 24 hours. It has a GI of 41 and a GL of 5.
The fibrous coat around seeds and plant cell walls acts as a physical barrier, slowing down access of enzymes to the starch inside the cells. It has an average GI value of 41.
Sourdough bread is made with dough that contains a lactobacillus culture and yeast. Acids in foods slow down stomach empting, thereby slowing the rate at which the starch can be digested. Because sourdough bread contains both lactic and propionic acids, produced by the natural fermentation of starch and sugars of the yeast, it causes a decrease in the rate of absorption into the blood stream and lowers the GI of wheat bread to 53 and GL to 10.
The bottom line
One of the greatest changes you can make in your diet to control your level s of blood sugar is to bread in moderation. Even breads that have a low glycemic index and a low glycemic load, such as those made with coarse and intact grains, should be eaten with caution. Average white and wheat breads should be avoided because they will raise your blood sugar at even higher levels than sugar.
But, since everybody is different, when eating bread, check your blood sugar before and after eating it. Remember that the amount you eat also has an impact in your blood glucose level. You may want to eat just one slice of bread at a time instead of two to prevent a high rise in blood sugar.
To your health!
Emilia Klapp, R.D., B.S.